nof1l.gif (4731 bytes)


F1 Merchandise

Formula 1 news, results and statistics when you need it

Are Ferrari using traction control already ? 

blank.gif (809 bytes)
blank.gif (809 bytes)

Other Topics

Recent comments by Jordan's driver Heinz Harald Frentzen have brought this issue into the spotlight. When a respected driver such as Frentzen says "And now I give you an unconditional statement: In the past 18 races, I had plenty of opportunity to trail behind Ferrari cars or machinery powered by Ferrari engines. And one thing was particularly remarkable: out of tight corners, these cars had a pretty stunning acceleration, combined with a misfiring engine. For me, it is beyond doubt that somehow Ferrari managed to develop an engine software which reduces the power by a certain margin to the extent that the driven wheels don’t spin." It makes one think, are Ferrari using traction control already or is it just a clever interpretation of the rules that all other teams are trying as well ? Also one would ask, why is it that Ferrari were the only team to oppose the reintroduction of traction control ? 

What do you think ? Have Your Say   (What others are saying)

(only your first name and last initial will appear under your comments)

Name:

Email address:

Country:

Comments:

 

All comments will be reviewed before publishing. Comments will be published within 24 hours of submission. Views and comments appearing on this page do not reflect the opinion of NewsOnF1.com.

NewsOnF1.com cannot guarantee that all comments will be published. NewsOnF1.com has the right to edit comments if deemed necessary.


What others are saying:

Ferrari are probably not using TC.  MS might be left foot braking out of corners, emulating the 'illegal' McLaren third pedal of a couple of years ago, and there might be some software which works off lateral g/throttle/brake sensors to limit engine power under the combination of these three things.  That could simply be called 'rev-limiting' software and be deemed legal. Maybe that's what HHF heard.  Remember Benetton in 1996/97, with Berger & Alesi?  They had several races where they simply streaked past three rows of the grid at the start - impossible without TC.  And they never got caught.  It's easy to do with software that 'eats itself' after one application, eg at the start of a race.  Lets' not forget a couple of other things.  MS has the best feel for any car right now and has had for a few years - that's why he can storm the tracks.  MS also married HHF's old girlfriend, so it's no surprise HHF gets upset when the guy that stole his gal also leaves him for dead on the track.  And what about Jos the Boss?  He was able to keep his car on the track ahead of MS and Arrows probably don't have TC. So stop whining and put the foot down! - Dave - Australia


Lyngkilde basically said what i was thinking, i also would like to mention to all the ppl
saying that why would Ferrari risk using TC, well i think its because they know that even if they get caught (highly unlikely, which is why TC is coming back), Ferrari know that there are a softer set of rules for Ferrari, when it comes to the FIA regulations (remember Sepang 1999 and the illegal barge boards)
 (remember Interlagos 2000 and the wing infringements, only DC was penalised) - N-ona- mu$ - Australia

Of course Ferrari is not using Traction Control. If they were, they would have *FANTASTIC* starts, and they do NOT. Look at last year - Mika had better starts than Michael at every race. And this year, Barrichello's starts have been AWFUL, while Coulthards have been fantastic. If anyone is using it, it is McLaren.

Furthermore, if Ferrari had illegal traction control, do you really believe they would also install it on Saubers car? Are you people crazy? If you are going to break the rules, you keep it SECRET.

Some people cannot face the truth that Ferrari have the best car this year. Tough luck, get ready for a year when Ferrari dominates - Peter - USA


I read the comments of - Lyngkilde - Denmark  and Shahrukh - K - India . These two bozos know nothing about F1, that is apparent. They think that Ferrari can get away with anything, eh? Then *WHY* was Michael Schumacher disqualified from 2nd place in the World Championship in 1997 when he hit Villeneuve? Hmm? *WHY* does Barrichello have such bad starts if Ferrari has traction control?

Nice try, guys. Face it, Ferrari has finally built a great car, and you two are SORE LOSERS.

Grow up, and take your defeat like *MEN*, not like a bunch of whiny losers - John - USA


Yes they do !!!! Just look on today's race in Sepang. From 11th to 1st, in 6 laps, and then go ahead by almost 1.min. when the rain is like monsoon................ ??????
Barrichello is NOT a rain specialist, but he did almost the same.
This is impossible without traction control - Lyngkilde - Denmark


I believe Ferrari may be using TC as i believe other teams also are, although i'm not to fond of Frentzen i do respect his opinion when it come's to this as he knows what he's talking about, to make such a comment publicly you'd have to be sure of what your saying. As someone already wrote i think the Mclaren's will start to perform better come TC. infact i wonder if they have built the car around the concept of TC knowing that it will perform better with it but not so well just now with the knowledge that the majority of the season will be run with TC. Also even if these comment's are not true i'm sure the FIA could hold an investigation, it's a bit strange they've not said that they will, aferall that's what they are there for. 
The reason Ferrari would be so opposed to traction control is that if they are using it they would want to keep that advantage by ensuring no one else could use it - Ross - Scotland.


I do not think that Ferrari used traction control during the past season and therefore am of the opinion that they won the championship fair and square. If one consider that while driving for Benetton, MS was always a very good starter and then look at last season where one will notice that even though he grabbed a couple of poles, he messed up each and every one of them with very poor starts during the races. That is very uncharacteristic of TC.
As for this season, we will have to wait and see but again I think that there is too much at stake to be caught with illegal gadgets. I do not think for one minute that they are using means that the others are not. They are just doing it better.
Consider this: look at this year's qualifying times. They are very much faster than last year even though technical changes have been brought in to reduce lap times. I doubt very much that engine development can be so dramatic to improve lap times by up to 5 or 6 seconds (remember the technical changes was supposed to have knocked of about 3 seconds) in the space of 4 months unless steps have been taken to alter the power delivery on to the track. If you want to call that TC then so be it. Bear in mind that at Malaysia the first 12 cars on the grid all beat last year's pole and in Australia the last car to officially qualify would have been on the second row last year, then it must be concluded that whatever Ferrari is accused of doing, they are all doing it - Johan - South Africa. 


Traction control or Engine mapping?  That really is the question.  In terms or legality or illegality I believe the system that Ferrari developed and uses, along with it's customers is in fact legal.  They would not risk being caught or have any damage to their reputation especially as defending champions.  Last year does show that the system Ferrari used was not the magical traction control that eliminated wheel spin, look at Michael Schumacher's starts and the fact that they had wheel spin.  Ferrari engine governance was most beneficial in the turns and as anyone can tell you the noise signature of a Ferrari is the most distinctive on the circuit.
Whatever system that they use and I am sure other teams had developed similar systems within the legal boundaries, the reintroduction of traction control was the only way to prevent any further innuendo within the sport for this matter
- Steven P - Australia


Lets assume for a moment that Ferrari had been able to map the engine to provide some form of torque resistance capability. Would they then leave this in place for client engines, I doubt it, particularly given the risk of exposure with Barcelona so close.

Lets then look at the reasons for Ferrari to oppose traction control. Ferrari had/have a very strong engine in a well sorted chassis and the best driver in the field. No-one had less to gain from introducing TC. Whatever benefits they gained came at a huge cost in lost competitive advantage with the drivers input being less significant and the intrinsic balance of the car being compensated for by TC.

If it were just Ferrari then one would have to question possible pushing of the legal envelope but I don't believe they would pass that down through client engines.

On balance, no, I don't believe that what Frentzen heard was TC at work but perhaps a characteristic of Ferrari's engine note under load
- Geoff H - Australia


Of course Ferrari are using traction control. How else would they match up to the pace of the McLarens. I think everybody knows it but HHF has been the first one to voice his opinion. The only resort for Ferrari was to do illegal things and have managed to win the championship by doing so. I just have one question for them: Are they happy by winning the championship unfairly? The truth will be out when they lose the advantage come Barcelona. MARK MY WORDS!!! - Shahrukh - K - India


Here we go again,
Mr. Frentzen has nothing else to de as inventing an idea again against Michael Schumacher.
Let´s be reasonable about building rumours. We all know, that Michael and H.H have never been the best friends so it's easy to create a phantom to damage reputations. He is not only accusing Ferrari, but even his personal rival, Michael Schumacher.  Are we forgetting already how hard this man worked and how many times he risked his health and life only to bring back the scratched glory of Ferrari?  So let's be logical and not polemic. The Parcque Ferme is the  place is the final place, were such accusation might raise an eyebrow or two.
Ferrari and Schumacher deserved the title and they worked long and hard to develop a car that can win - Freddy P - Germany


I think this question will be answered in Barcelona when all the teams will be using traction control. If Ferrari will loosce the advantage then I guess we can say they are (were) using traction control - Rok F - Slovenia.


Honestly, I don't know, but in my opinion they don't. I can not see Michael Schumacher, Jean Todt or Rubens Barrichello cheating. The Ferrari world is small. The F1 World is small too and I can't visualise those three risking their reputation for 4 races. HHF can accuse everybody which is passing him (see McLaren was accused having a sort of TCS called CANOE SYSTEM 2 or 3 years ago). In fact HHF (which was one of the few gentlemen drivers ) did retract the accusation against Nick Heidfeld taking a defensive  position. If YOU watch the tape from Australia You can see MS car smoking the tires like hell but I couldn't see McLaren, BAR, Jordan or Williams. So based  on HHF INTUITION I suppose those teams already have a hidden traction control. IF you'll be in MICHAEL SCHUMACHER place ARE YOU GOING TO RISK EVERYTHING  like JOHNSON? My best regards - Marian - Romanian living in the US


Yes I do think that Ferrari is using traction control and they have all reasons to do so: the championship for manufacturer. Remember... they where trying for the past 14 years... and any way of gaining this championship was taken by Ferrari... legal or not (by FIA rules) - Jacques G - Canada.


I have very little doubt that HH is correct in his deduction. Ferrari are quite likely to push the envelope of legality very hard.  They do have almost guaranteed "forgiven" status by the FIA.  And, lets face it,  they have successfully overcome a number of breaches without penalty already. I would even go so far as to say that somehow I believe that Max agrees with HH. I am however puzzled as to why the track marshals do not pick up the association (misfiring plus good acceleration)?  I did not pick it up at Melbourne myself but then I was probably not at an appropriate corner!!  Bottom line though,  do not discount Nick Heidfeld's brilliant drive with Kimi R close on his heels (for his debut as well). Well done Sauber - Ian M - Australia.


Well, this issue can hardly be called debatable. I certainly don't think that Ferrari are using traction control. Why would they? After all, if they were to be caught the consequences will be grave. Frentzen had better learn to face it. His car is not good enough. He is just being a bad sportsman. I don't think he liked being beaten by Sauber. It hurt is pride and I don't really blame him, but speaking so stupidly wont do him any good. Plus if Ferrari and the other cars equipped with Ferrari-hybrid engines were to be using traction control they would surely be caught in the post-race car examination. Remember Mika Hakkinen finished first in Austria but McLaren were denied team points after they failed the post-race examination.
No. We shall only see traction control when Spain beckons the F1 season - Yaman - India


I don't think Ferrari would use illegal meanings to win races. They would be putting too much on the line. As for them being against the reinforcement of traction control, I just think that because they have a strong engine, and most of the other teams don't, it would not benefit them to have traction control reintroduced as much as it would if traction control was not reintroduced - Dan A - Brazil


Back To Top

We Recommend
F1 Tickets
Spanish F1 GP
Canadian F1 GP
British F1 GP
European F1 GP (Valencia)
Belgian F1 GP
Italian F1 GP
United States F1 GP
Abu Dhabi F1 GP
VIP F1 Paddock Club Tickets
MotoGP Tickets
Netherlands MotoGP
Catalunya MotoGP
Portuguese MotoGP
Valencia MotoGP
MotoGP VIP Village Tickets
more Motorsport Tours & Holidays
Australian F1 Grand Prix Tour package
Clipsal 500 Adelaide package
 

F1 Merchandise

Official 2009 F1 Season Review

Autocourse 2009 Annual

F1 Merchandise US

F1 Merchandise UK

Motorsport Magazines

Formula 1 Annuals

Formula 1 Yearbooks

Formula 1 Season Reviews

Formula 1 Technical Books

Formula 1 Design Books

The Official Tribute To Ayrton Senna
1960 To 1994

Formula 1 Books

Race Driving Books

Race Car Design Books


Ayrton Senna

Past Formula 1 Drivers