second race of the season leaves us with much to talk about.
From the race perspective we saw Williams dominate, Ferrari struggle and
McLaren slow and unreliable. Sauber and Renault certainly look as if
they will fight for 4th while Toyota continues to impress.
As for the controversy surrounding the clash between Michael and Juan
Pablo, was it anyone's fault ? And if it was, was it worth a 'pit lane
drive through penalty' ?
Of course you can comment on other aspects of the race - Have Your Say
(What others are saying)
(only your first name and last initial will appear under your comments)
will be reviewed before publishing. Comments will be published within 24 hours of
submission. Views and comments appearing on this page do not reflect the opinion of
NewsOnF1.com cannot guarantee that all comments will be
published. NewsOnF1.com reserves the right to edit comments if deemed necessary.
What others are saying:
Montoya`s penalty was wrong as it was a racing incident. Who
would've won had they got away clean?, Hmm I don't know for sure but the 3 on
the podium may have changed around, but they would of all been there (podium).
Ralf's thing looked so hooked up, Michael's car only looked good in the last
stint but it is Michael, and Montoya, well the boy is good. Ralf explaining
his win at the conference looked like a kid in a candy shop.
This will be the toughest racing we have seen for years. Regards Cooky -
That move of Schumi's at the start c'mon. Even I knew he was
going to do that before they even started. He was on pole but on the dirty
side of the track. Senna did it, so did Mansel, Prost, Mika, Damon, Jaques -
nothing new here. And yes he was lucky to finish 3rd. But as so many greats
have said before: "The better I got, the luckier I got" - Johan M
- South Africa
O.K., gentlemen, lets get this correct. On the first turn,
M. Schumacher had room to make the turn but was not going to give JPM the
opportunity to overtake him at the next left-hand turn, which is what would
have happened if the accident did not take place. Yes, JPM is a headstrong
young man who wants to beat M. Schumacher possibly more than he wants to win
the championship, but we cannot use this excuse for why the accident occurred.
The penalty was a poor one, and it would be nice if Mosley and Co. admitted
that a mistake was made. I believe that in Formula One, as in many other
sports, officials will tend to rule in favor of the "established
champion". I understand this action even though I don't agree with
Lastly, McLaren is in real trouble, regardless of their cautious optimism.
Lack of engine reliability, Raikkonen consistently running ahead of Coulthard,
and those god-awful black suits they all have to wear, all lead me to believe
that they will not be contenders this year! Renault or Sauber may actually
take 3rd for the championship.
Regardless, this season has already proven that it will be one of the best in
a long time. And lastly, why the **** isn't the U.S. set up for Sky Digital
yet??!! - Blas A - USA.
the Penalty was justified, it gives a warning signal in the
right direction, 'cos this years championship is going to be tight (as
everyone agrees) and we'll see too many close fights and running into , like
the ones we saw in the early 90s and 'til 97.
All JPM and Ralf got is a very fast and reliable car, not their talent or
Driving skills improved dramatically in about an year - GOP - NL
In all honesty I was just glad to see Michael not winning
again!! Montoya was a bit aggressive I must say, but F1 needs him at the
moment thats for sure. Ralf won't get an easier victory in his life, all he
had to do was keep going - all credit to him and the team cos that's what he
did. Great pity for Jenson losing third to Michael, but at least he came home
4th for 3 points. At least it blows the championship wide open now, certainly
doesn't look like Ferrari will walk away it now - Linda B - England
Guys I think you are giving Michael too much credit here.
First he slid into Juan, it was his fault yet Juan is penalised. What about
his move across at the start ? That was ridiculous even if it is allowed
(replay it and watch how severe it was).
Second, Schumacher yet again shows how lucky he his, he didn't finish third on
talent, remember how he won in Spain last year ? Same thing and I don't only
mean 3rd but even 4th or 5th or 6th, there is no way he would have passed
either of the McLaren's and then Barrichello (when does a Ferrari engine fail
????) had they stayed on the track. Juan on the other hand would have managed
third had Barrichello stayed on the track.
The penalty was a complete farce. Why ?? Ignoring all the Ralf-Barrichello
incidents this year and last year, when the last time Juan and Michael
touched, everybody was angry with Juan but it was exactly the same thing.
Michael on the outside and Juan locked his brakes and slid into Michael.
Anyone penalised then?
Don't get me wrong, Michael is a great driver but so is Juan. Remember this is
only the start of his second season and he is doing this. Watch out for him.
He is sending a clear message to Michael - ' Your time is up'. As for respect,
sorry but Michael never had respect for anyone on the track in the past. He is
starting to show some these days and you know why ? He knows his days are
numbered and he is trying every method in the book. (Just like the Mr. safety
In any case don't we want to see this happening ? Aren't we sick and tired of
one team dominating ? May the best win
(I still think though that Michael will win the Championship as he has a team
all for himself while Montoya and Ralf will keep taking away points from each
other but I will always respect Williams for that) - Simon B - Australia
I think it was very unfair the penalty to JP. Schumacher doesn't
need that kind of help. He's has demonstrate how dirty he run. he shows his
fear for JP. The way he start crossing all over is ...(no words) but he has
done it before, so what can you expect? - Jorge O - Columbia
SURPRISE!!!! OH yeaaa big surprises.
Race itself was a knights fight, but.....A surprise for 1-2 Williams, other
one little bit bigger Schummy in 3rd (honestly I thought he's lost), another
one, Ferrari reliability seems gone, not a big surprise Dennis final product
failed - too bad for Kimmi,
A BIG SURPRISE RENAULT AND JENSON WERE GREAT watch out McLaren and....Ferrari
Mantoya/Schumacher accident? Did I say something about the talent isn't enough
in the past? Well the incident was caused by Mantoya infatuation something
like "Hey I m Juan-Pablo watch out". Any good driver knows if you
got the front wing of your adversary behind your RHD front wheel, when you
turn right, you are outside and you don't intend to take him out you are going
to collect a lot of debris in your radiator(tire eventual) if other driver
doesn't back off (if there is enough room). Michael didn't had too much room
too, but the touch was well coordinated and in my opinion after a lot of
forcing the issue situation (in the past), Mantoya got the message 'Do Not
Expect Merci" My wish is to have the same situation on the track JPM with
Jaques or David. We are going to see some sparks.
The 10 seconds penalty is irelevant, JPM told us it cost him a race, what
about Michael? Was he a b...... lucky (these are DC words) guy? or smart and
Well... Gents If you respect yourself you are going to be respected by the
others. This is a common sense issue which works in both ways and in F1 has a
lot of sense.
My best regards to everyone - Marian - Romanian living in the US
I think Geoff gave a very accurate summary of the race
although I think Montoya gave Michael no room at all and left Michael with
absolutely nowhere to go. Montoya is a headstrong stubborn driver and he is
going to be involved in a lot more incidents before the end of the season. I
also think that Geoff's comment about the telecast was accurate although again
I think the end part was particularly bad with cameras focusing on Ralph's car
who had already won the race while there was still drama going on with the
other people still racing. Well done Geoff - well said - Johan M - South
Sirs, Great race. Really hot so some had to go, though I
wish Rubens wasn't one of them. Great parts are the 1-2 finish by JPM and
Ralf, but my thing is how the Champ came from last place to finish third to
stay ahead in the points race, I'm looking forward o another great
Oh, I hope they don't change the engine rules till next year, after all, the
season is already started. happy Motoring. DB - USA
A pity that the stewards awarded the drive through penalty
to Montoya, in my opinion it was a 'racing incident' and should not have
warranted any action. The race showed the superiority of one car/driver, and
that wasn't Montoya or RS. Michael Schumacher lost significantly more time in
the pits than Montoya, with a very slow inlap adding to the delay of fitting a
new nose. He then had to fight through the entire field to get back to the
podium. I cannot accept that he would not have been on Montoya's tail from the
time of the incident onwards and may have found his opportunity to get back
into the lead. I also suspect that he had some problems with the setup of the
car, or other damage to the aerodynamics after the incident. He was
understeering quite significantly and never as tidy as he normally is through
With the '02 car now a certainty to start soon I think MS will again go back
to the head of the leader board pretty quickly.
Montoya is probably the best opportunistic overtaker in the field, he
capitalised brilliantly on Schumacher's very slow start.
Ralph (and I'm certainly not a member of his fan club) drove the perfect race,
staying out of trouble and picking the strategy that worked on the day.
The McLarens were slow. Kimi may have ended up in a reasonable position but
one finish from four starts is not going to keep them up with the Ferrari and
Williams. Of particular interest was the relative situations of Raikkonen and Coulthard.
Coulthard started behind Raikkonen and was not making any impression on the
1.2 second gap between them. After 6 seasons with an evolving McLaren car I
cannot see him getting any more from the car than he can today. With only 2
starts in a new car, plus a few weeks of practice, after what has been a
remarkably short career, Raikkonen can only get better. I believe that Coulthard
will be the bridesmaid again this year.
Button drove an excellent race (actually he had an excellent weekend) and
showed the Renault is certainly a match for the Sauber. Before the season
started I felt that 4th place would be a contest between Sauber and Jordan but
now Renault is looking much more likely to challenge for it. Trulli is a
brilliant 'hot lap' driver and Button did a great job in outqualifying his
Bernoldi was the surprise of the day. To retake position from Schumacher
(quite legitimately given they were fighting for position) and to then hold
the vastly superior car for a few corners was a clear indication that he
(Bernoldi) is a much more committed racer than I had given him credit
Congratulations to The Heretic on a good call on McLaren, I still see them as
a comfortable third but they obviously have no answers for the Williams or
Ferrari on this type of track. They may well be on their way down, but I
cannot see Mercedes sitting back and accepting that. The chassis seems ok, at
least for Raikkonen (he did post fastest lap in Melbourne) but they need more
power and reliability if they are going to challenge again for a top spot.
Norbert Haug will, I think, be saying much the same thing about now.
One comment I will make about the Sepang race, the feed for English TV -
picked up by Channel 9 in Australia - was terrible, particularly in the early
part of the race. The Malaysian Director should be sent to any of the other
circuits (or perhaps just watch another race on TV) and then have the term
'continuity' explained to him. I have never seen such a disjointed telecast,
with the camera's jumping from place to place and offering no feel for what is
happening in the race. Admittedly, by the end of the telecast it was much
better - Geoff H - Australia
The penalty was totally unfair. If there was any fault it
was Michael's who came wide towards and touched Juan Pablo. Seems like the
organizers don't like this newcomer (Montoya) to beat the untouchable and
Even Schumacher stated that the penalty was too harsh on Montoya - Juan C -
Join 6 'n'
Pole and see how your predictions stack up against the others. Register